Microsoft Most Valuable Professional

Chris Pietschmann

An MVP From Wisconsin



Vista Experience Update: Disk Defragmenter Revisited

About 5 months ago, way back when Vista RTM'd, I posted about how Vista now automatically defragments your hard drives. This is a really neat feature, especially since I would never remember to defrag until my system started to get noticably slow. So, I thought I would revisit this to just see how well is it working.

But, How well does the automatically scheduled defrag work?

I was wonder this, so I decided to check the defrag stats available from within the Disk Defragmenter tool. And to my dismay, they removed that display. I figured there's got to be a way; so I search my favorite search engine.

And, I found this post: Whatever Happened to ... The Defragmentation App?

Apparently, the only way to view the fragmentation stats is to use the defrag tool from the command line. Well, I guess the stats really weren't usefull to the average use, so this works; but couldn't they've just left an "Analysis Report" button in the GUI of the tool?

Steps to view the Fragmentation Analysis Report for the C drive

  1. Run the Command Prompt.
    Note: Don't forget to right-click the shortcut and click "Run as administrator"
  2. Type the following in the command line: defrag c: -a
  3. Press Enter and in a few moments it's display the Percent file fragmentation

My results of the auto-scheduled Defragmentation after 5 months

After running Vista for 5 months and doing the usual install/uninstall and write/delete of programs and files (which usually results in about 22% fragmentation for me within a few months) I see that my C drive fragmentation is only at 1%. Looks good to me, and I haven't experienced any performance degradation over this time period either.

Conclusion

The auto-scheduling of the extremely important Disk Defragmenter tool has made my system (and presumably everyone elses) easier to manage over the long term. One less thing I need to think about (and do) is always nice; besided this is very important for those who don't even know (I'm refering to the average user) they have to run the defragmenter. Way to go Microsoft on this small improvement with such a big impact!

Currently rated 4.8 by 4 people

  • Currently 4.75/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Categories: General
Posted by crpietschmann on Tuesday, April 24, 2007 10:29 PM
Permalink | Comments (3) | Post RSSRSS comment feed

Related posts

Comments

Michael in NC

Friday, September 14, 2007 7:32 PM

Michael in NC

The only bad thing about this feature is that it has to be scheduled when the computer is going to be on. This is great for office workers and the such, but for gamers running Vista IMO its best to turn of the schedule drag and drop a shortcut onto the desktop and run it manually whenever your not going to be using your computer for a half hour or more. If your in the middle of a intense application or game the defragmentation of your hard drive running will cause your computer to lag out bad, i say this and ive got 8Gigs ram and a 8500 GT OC graphics card with 512Mb onboard. But yes microsoft did do a good job implementing this for the average user. Im sure it dont take much out of running word proccessing programs while running in the background.

lars

Friday, November 09, 2007 6:41 PM

lars

For me the most stupid thing is, that you can't even chose which HD to defragment! it defragments all HD:s after each other.
Smart? Don't think so... I have 4 external HD:s, and it takes quite a while for windows to defragment them all.

Jeff

Sunday, December 16, 2007 10:23 AM

Jeff

I love defragmenting, but the best part, the graphics, are gone!!! Oh woh as me!!! I shall never enjoy defragmenting again.

Comments are closed

About the author

I'm Chris Pietschmann, go to the About Me page to learn more about me.

Search

Sponsors

Web.Maps.VE - ASP.NET AJAX Virtual Earth Mapping Server Control

Recent comments

Disclaimer


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License, unless explicitly stated otherwise within the posted content.
© Copyright 2004 - 2008 Chris Pietschmann